Certificate of occupancy vs point-of-sale inspection

Last updated

A building-code certificate of occupancy, a resale use-and-occupancy certificate, and a point-of-sale inspection report are different papers. Here is which event produces which one.

Closing folders collect papers with nearly identical names. A certificate of occupancy, a certificate of compliance, a certificate of inspection, and a use-and-occupancy certificate can all sit in the same PDF stack. They are not interchangeable with each other. One is a building-code permission tied to construction or a change in how a building is used. Another is a housing-inspection product tied to a sale. A third, in Pennsylvania, is a resale certificate created by a different statute from the construction certificate.

If the wrong document is in the file, the title company can still be waiting on a city release while everyone thinks the house is "certified." Match the paper to the event that created it, then confirm the current form with the building official or the housing office for that address. Contract disputes about which paper was promised are a question for a real estate lawyer, not for a city receptionist.

A building-code certificate follows construction or a change of use

Minnesota's building code states the construction rule directly. Minnesota Rules, part 1300.0220, says no building or structure may be used or occupied, and no change in the existing occupancy classification may be made, until the building official has issued a certificate of occupancy. Issuing that certificate is not approval of a code violation. A city may choose whether to require the certificate for certain "U" occupancies, accessory structures built under the International Residential Code, and used manufactured homes moved into the jurisdiction. A building that was already legally occupied when the code was adopted may keep that occupancy without a new certificate, unless the use changes. Changes in the character or use of an existing structure have to meet the state building or conservation code chapters the rule names.

The same rule tells the building official what to put on the certificate after an inspection finds no violations of the code or other laws that department enforces: permit number, address, owner, a compliance statement, the official's name, the code edition, the use and occupancy classification, the construction type, whether a sprinkler system is provided, and any special permit conditions. A temporary certificate is allowed before the whole permit is finished, if the portion can be occupied safely, and the official sets how long that temporary paper lasts. The official may suspend or revoke a certificate in writing if it was issued in error, based on wrong information, or if the building or its use violates an ordinance or the code.

Minneapolis applies that state rule in its own certificate-of-occupancy office, which is not the Truth in Sale of Housing desk. The city says a certificate of occupancy is required before a new building can be occupied, and a new one is required when the building's use or occupancy classification changes. It is valid for the life of the building, or until that use or classification changes. The building has to pass the ordinary construction inspections, such as mechanical and plumbing, and a final certificate-of-occupancy inspection. The city's policy sheet adds that there is no fee for that occupancy inspection, though penalty fees can apply if a reinspection is needed, and that the permit applicant's representative should call 612-673-2327 twenty business days before the date they want to occupy. The policy also quotes the state code: a certificate is required before any new building is occupied and before an existing building is used for a new purpose.

Pennsylvania writes a parallel construction rule in the Uniform Construction Code regulations, not in a point-of-sale ordinance. Under 34 Pa. Code § 403.65, a residential building may not be used or occupied without a certificate of occupancy issued by a building code official. The official must issue it within 5 business days after receiving a final inspection report that shows compliance with the Uniform Construction Code and ordinance, or within 10 business days in cities of the first class. The certificate has to carry the permit number and address, the owner's name and address, a description of the portion covered, a statement that the portion was inspected for Uniform Construction Code compliance, the official's name, the code edition, whether an automatic sprinkler system is provided, and any special stipulations. The official may certificate a portion that independently complies, may issue a temporary certificate for a portion that can be occupied safely, and may suspend or revoke a certificate issued in error, on incorrect information, or in violation of the code. A hearing before the board of appeals is available before revocation. (pacodeandbulletin.gov)

None of those rules is triggered by listing a house. They are triggered by occupying a new building, occupying after permitted work, or changing the occupancy classification.

A point-of-sale file usually holds a different certificate

Shaker Heights, Ohio, never calls its sale paperwork a certificate of occupancy. The seller files a point-of-sale application online before signing a contract with a buyer, then schedules a city inspection. The inspection is a visual look at the interior and exterior. For a single-family or two-family house it takes about 90 minutes. Apartment buildings take longer, and the fire department inspects common areas; fire-code items go into the same report. The city asks owners to allow at least two weeks from the application, and three to four weeks in the spring market. Posted fees are $200 for a single-family house, $300 for a two-family house, $150 for a condominium, and $200 for the first apartment unit plus $50 for each additional unit. (shakerheightsoh.gov)

After that inspection the seller receives one of two sale documents. A certificate of compliance means the property passed, and it may be transferred within 24 months of the initial inspection. A certificate of inspection means the inspector found violations that have to be corrected within 90 days, whether or not the house actually sells. Taking the listing off the market does not stop that 90-day correction clock. Before title transfers, either the violations are corrected or funds equal to 150 percent of the estimated repair cost go into an escrow account the city holds. (shakerheightsoh.gov)

Euclid uses yet another name. Section 1759.04 of the Codified Ordinances says no person may convey or sell any interest in a dwelling, building, or structure, by land contract or otherwise, without giving the buyer a current certificate of code compliance before the conveyance. If the units are not free of building and housing code violations, the buyer assumes them by filing an assumption application and must correct them within 180 days of the transfer. Missed corrections can be prosecuted under section 1703.99. The certificate itself is issued only on full compliance, and it shows the seller's name and address and the date of issuance. That is a transfer document. It is not the Minnesota or Pennsylvania building-code certificate described above. (codelibrary.amlegal.com)

When a real occupancy certificate can stand in for a sale report

Minneapolis is the clearest example of the two papers touching, and also of their different lifespans. The Truth in Sale of Housing page says single-family houses, duplexes, townhouses, and first-time condominium conversions need an evaluation, and the seller must have a full report before showing the property. A report is not required if the city has issued a certificate of code compliance after bringing a property out of condemnation, which is good for up to one year, or a certificate of occupancy for a newly built property, which is good for one sale after the city issues it.

Read those two Minneapolis pages together. The building-safety office says the occupancy certificate lasts for the life of the building, until the use changes. The housing-evaluation office says that same certificate excuses only one sale. The second sale of that new house needs a Truth in Sale of Housing report unless some other listed exemption applies. A certificate that still hangs in the mechanical room is not, by itself, a forever pass on the sale evaluation.

Saint Paul draws the line at the unit, not just the building. Its Truth-in-Sale of Housing report is disclosure only. Single-family homes, duplexes, condominiums, and townhomes need an evaluation before they are marketed. A condominium with its own parcel identification number still needs that evaluation even when the building has a certificate of occupancy, because the city says the occupancy certificate covers common areas and not each unit. Buildings with three or more units that do not have an individual parcel number, plus commercial and mixed-use buildings, are outside that evaluation. An alternative the city will accept is a valid certificate of code compliance or a current certificate of occupancy, and either of those substitutes is good for one year, or 365 consecutive days, from issuance or from the last inspection. The ordinary evaluation report has the same one-year life and is valid for only one sale by the owner named on it. (stpaul.gov)

Bloomington's time-of-sale code has a narrower new-construction exemption. Section 14.523, as the city summarizes it, does not apply to a newly constructed dwelling when title transfers to the first owner. The exemption is that first transfer, not every later resale of the same address. The city's report and certificate of compliance are valid for one year from issuance and only for the owner named on the report.

Pennsylvania uses the occupancy words twice, on purpose

Act 99 of 2000, the Municipal Code and Ordinance Compliance Act, is the resale statute. It is not § 403.65. The act defines a use and occupancy certificate as a certificate a municipality issues stating that the property meets ordinances and codes and may be used or occupied as intended. A temporary use and occupancy certificate is what the municipality issues when a resale inspection finds a violation but no substantial violation; the purchaser may live in or fully use the property while correcting those items. A temporary access certificate is what it issues when the inspection finds at least one substantial violation. That paper lets the purchaser onto the property to correct the substantial items. A new occupant who has not lived there before may not occupy during the temporary-access term. Tenants already in a tenant-occupied property may stay, at the discretion of code enforcement, based on whether the place is fit for people to live in. (legis.state.pa.us)

A substantial violation, in that act, is a violation of an adopted building, housing, property-maintenance, or fire code, or of a maintenance, health, or safety nuisance ordinance, that makes a building or part of it unfit for human habitation and that is found during the municipal inspection and disclosed in the municipal report. "Unfit" includes a significant increase in fire or accident hazards, inadequate sanitary facilities, vermin infestation, or disrepair, dilapidation, or structural defects where rehabilitation and repair would cost more than one-half of the agreed purchase price. If a municipality requires a resale certificate, it issues the full certificate when the inspection finds no violations, the temporary use-and-occupancy certificate when it finds violations that are not substantial, and the temporary access certificate when it finds a substantial violation. The act says the municipality may not require escrow, a bond, or similar financial security as a condition of issuing the certificate. That prohibition does not stop the municipality from requiring permits before work starts. (legis.state.pa.us)

The purchaser of a property known to be in violation or substantial violation has 12 months from the date of purchase to bring it into compliance or demolish the building in accordance with law. The municipality may agree to a longer period. It may not shorten the 12 months. Missing that deadline can revoke the temporary certificate, expose the purchaser to local rules on occupying without a certificate, and bring personal liability for the repair or demolition cost plus a fine of not less than $1,000 and not more than $10,000. (legis.state.pa.us)

So a Pennsylvania closing can legitimately involve both a Uniform Construction Code certificate, if there was permitted work or a new house, and an Act 99 resale certificate, if that municipality requires one at transfer. Asking "do we have the occupancy certificate?" is not a precise question until someone names which statute.

For how individual boroughs schedule the resale inspection, see Pennsylvania resale use and occupancy certificates.

South Euclid's ordinance title is easy to misread

In March 2010 South Euclid passed ordinance 11-10, which the city itself titles "Registration of Vacant Buildings and Certificates of Occupancy for Vacant Buildings." The program the housing page actually describes is not a Minnesota-style building-code occupancy certificate. South Euclid says it does not have a point-of-sale inspection for occupied houses. A vacant building needs a vacant-building registration and an interior and exterior inspection before any interest is sold or transferred. The certificate of inspection from that visit is valid for one year and for one transfer only. (southeuclid.gov)

If violations remain at transfer, the buyer files an assumption-of-violations form and a party to the transfer opens an account with the title agent for 100 percent of the city-established hold for Class A violations. The building commissioner sets that hold from a fee schedule. The city says the hold is not the full cost of the work and that a buyer should do separate due diligence on the real repair bill. All violations have to be corrected, and a certificate of compliance obtained, within six months of the title transfer. Nobody may occupy the vacant building until that certificate of compliance is issued. The fee for the certificate of compliance is $200, escrow is not released before it is issued, and occupying early can mean court. Registration of the vacancy itself is $200 a year, due when the building becomes vacant, and the city warns of daily fines up to $1,000. Owner-occupied houses that recently became vacant may qualify for a vacant exemption; that is a separate application, not an automatic pass. (southeuclid.gov)

The ordinance title uses "certificates of occupancy." The documents the city tells you to obtain for a vacant sale are a certificate of inspection and, before anyone moves in, a certificate of compliance.

Which paper to ask the office for

Use the event, not the nickname on the listing sheet.

  • New building, or an existing building whose occupancy classification is changing: ask the building official about the certificate of occupancy under the state building code. In Minneapolis that is Construction Code Services, 612-673-2327, not the Truth in Housing line.
  • Ordinary resale in Shaker Heights or Euclid: ask housing or building staff for the point-of-sale certificate of compliance, certificate of inspection, or certificate of code compliance. Do not ask them to "pull the C of O" unless permitted construction is also in the file. (shakerheightsoh.gov)
  • First sale of a newly built Minneapolis house: ask whether that occupancy certificate is being used as the one sale the Truth in Sale of Housing page allows in place of an evaluation. Ask again on the next sale.
  • Saint Paul condominium: look up whether the unit has its own parcel identification number. A building-wide occupancy certificate does not replace the unit evaluation when it does. (stpaul.gov)
  • Pennsylvania municipality that inspects at resale: ask whether the file needs an Act 99 use-and-occupancy, temporary use-and-occupancy, or temporary access certificate, and separately whether any open building permit still needs a § 403.65 certificate. (legis.state.pa.us)
  • Vacant house in South Euclid: ask for the vacant-building inspection and, before occupancy, the certificate of compliance. An occupied South Euclid house is outside the point-of-sale program the city describes. (southeuclid.gov)

Fees, forms, and which office answers the phone change. The citations above are the pages and statutes reviewed for this guide. Call the office that enforces the address before you treat any of them as the rule for a particular closing.

Sources

  1. Truth-in-Sale of Housing | City of Saint Paul
  2. 34 Pa. Code § 403.65, Certificate of occupancy
  3. Municipal Code and Ordinance Compliance Act, Act 99 of 2000
  4. Point of Sale Procedure | City of Shaker Heights
  5. Euclid Codified Ordinances § 1759.04
  6. Housing | City of South Euclid

Free checklist · PDF

Home Seller's Point-of-Sale Inspection Checklist

The city and county requirements that commonly pop up when you sell a home, and a timeline so they don't delay closing.

Free. We email you the download link, plus an occasional plain-English guide. Unsubscribe any time. We never sell your email. Privacy